Skip navigation
Mobile menu is now open
    • Publications
    • Perspectives
    • Projects and tools
    • Events
    • People
    • About
    • SEI Africa
    • SEI Asia
    • SEI Headquarters
    • SEI Latin America
    • SEI Oxford
    • SEI Tallinn
    • SEI US
    • SEI York
    • Climate
      • Adaptation
      • Mitigation
      • Finance
      • Climate services
      • Short lived climate pollutants
      • Fossil fuels
      • Disaster risk
      • Climate policy
    • Water
      • Sanitation
      • Water resources
      • Disaster risk
      • Food and agriculture
      • Cities
      • Adaptation
      • Water-Energy-Food Nexus
      • Planning and modelling
    • Air
      • Short lived climate pollutants
      • Transport
      • Cities
      • Household energy
      • Food and agriculture
      • Pollution
    • Land
      • Food and agriculture
      • Forests
      • Cities
      • Land use
      • Ecosystems
    • Energy
      • Energy access
      • Household energy
      • Sustainable lifestyles
      • Renewables
      • Fossil fuels
      • Transport
      • Planning and modelling
    • Governance
      • Finance
      • Public policy
      • Geopolitics
      • Sustainable Development Goals
      • Innovation
      • Participation
    • Economy
      • Supply chains
      • Bioeconomy
      • Finance
      • Business
      • Behaviour and choice
      • Sustainable lifestyles
      • Innovation
    • Gender
      • Household energy
      • Sanitation
      • Participation
      • Behaviour and choice
      • Food and agriculture
      • Adaptation
      • Disaster risk
      • Renewables
    • Health
      • Pollution
      • Sanitation
      • Disaster risk
      • Household energy
      • Cities
      • Food and agriculture
      • Well-being

    Connect with SEI

    SEI Logo
    Centres
      SEI Logo
      Stockholm Environment Institute
      • Publications
      • Perspectives
      • Projects and tools
      • Events
      • People
      • About

      SEI Topics

      Climate Water Air Land Energy Governance Economy Gender Health
      • Climate
        • Adaptation
        • Mitigation
        • Finance
        • Climate services
        • Short lived climate pollutants
        • Fossil fuels
        • Disaster risk
        • Climate policy
      • Water
        • Sanitation
        • Water resources
        • Disaster risk
        • Food and agriculture
        • Cities
        • Adaptation
        • Water-Energy-Food Nexus
        • Planning and modelling
      • Air
        • Short lived climate pollutants
        • Transport
        • Cities
        • Household energy
        • Food and agriculture
        • Pollution
      • Land
        • Food and agriculture
        • Forests
        • Cities
        • Land use
        • Ecosystems
      • Energy
        • Energy access
        • Household energy
        • Sustainable lifestyles
        • Renewables
        • Fossil fuels
        • Transport
        • Planning and modelling
      • Governance
        • Finance
        • Public policy
        • Geopolitics
        • Sustainable Development Goals
        • Innovation
        • Participation
      • Economy
        • Supply chains
        • Bioeconomy
        • Finance
        • Business
        • Behaviour and choice
        • Sustainable lifestyles
        • Innovation
      • Gender
        • Household energy
        • Sanitation
        • Participation
        • Behaviour and choice
        • Food and agriculture
        • Adaptation
        • Disaster risk
        • Renewables
      • Health
        • Pollution
        • Sanitation
        • Disaster risk
        • Household energy
        • Cities
        • Food and agriculture
        • Well-being
      1. SEI
      2. Publications
      • Journal articles
      • 21 September 2018
      • DOI: 10.1186/s13750-018-0133-3
      • SEI Stockholm,
      Share
      To the article Open access

      Response to “Every ROSE has its thorns”

      In this article, the authors explain the thinking behind development of the ROSES reporting standards for systematic evidence syntheses, in response to comments on an earlier article introducing ROSES.

      Haddaway, N. R., Macura, B., Whaley, P. and Pullin, A. S. (2018). Response to “Every ROSE has its thorns”. Environmental Evidence, 7(1). https://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13750-018-0133-3

      Read the original article introducing ROSES

      • ROSES RepOrting standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses: Pro forma, flow-diagram and descriptive summary of the plan and conduct of environmental systematic reviews and systematic maps

      Read the original comment article

      • Every ROSE has its thorns
      Visit journal website:
      To the article  Open access
      SEI authors:
      Neal Haddaway
      Biljana Macura
      Tags:
      methodology evidence synthesis
      Share:

      You might be interested in

      ROSES RepOrting standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses: Pro forma, flow-diagram and descriptive summary of the plan and conduct of environmental systematic reviews and systematic maps

      • Journal articles
      • Land
      • 12 April 2018
      Flower field in sunset

      Mistra EviEM

      • Project
      • Governance
      • Land
      • 2012 - 2018
      • Sweden

      Systematic reviews and maps as tools for applying behavioral ecology to management and policy

      • Journal articles
      • 15 October 2018

      Sign up to the SEI newsletter

      Get the latest updates and invitations to your inbox with SEI’s newsletter.

      • Privacy policy
      • Jobs
      • Cookie notice
      • Press room
      • Accessibility
      • RSS feeds
      • Contact
      • Social media
      • Whistleblowing
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn
      Centres:
      • SEI Africa
      • SEI Asia
      • SEI Headquarters
      • SEI Latin America
      • SEI Oxford
      • SEI Tallinn
      • SEI US
      • SEI York

      © Stockholm Environment Institute 2022