Skip navigation
Journal article

Brazil’s environmental leadership at risk

This article highlights concerns for the newly elected government in Brazil regarding development of major infrastructure and natural resource extraction projects in protected areas and indigenous lands in the country.

Toby Gardner / Published on 7 November 2014

Read the paper  Closed access

Citation

J. Ferreira, L. E. O. C. Aragão, J. Barlow, P. Barreto, E. Berenguer, M. Bustamante, T. A. Gardner, A. C. Lees, A. Lima, J. Louzada, L. Parry, C. A. Peres, R. Pardini, P. S. Pompeu, M. Tabarelli, J. Zuanon (2014). Brazil's environmental leadership at risk. Science 346(6210), Policy Forum section, pp. 706-707.

Over the past two decades, Brazil has emerged as an environmental leader. The country has earned praise for the expansion of its protected area network and reductions in Amazon deforestation. Yet these successes are being compromised by development pressures and shifts in legislation.

In this article, a team of Brazilian and international researchers examine the implications of recent legislative changes and proposals currently being debated in the Brazilian Congress that could open up 10% of strictly protected lands to mining development. The analysis raises four key issues. First, the existing protected area network is critical for conserving Brazil’s ecosystems, despite claims to the contrary. Second, there is potential for lasting environmental damage from effects associated with many large-scale development projects. Third, environmental mitigation policies are poorly conceived, fall short of international minimum standards for mitigation, and are unlikely to succeed. Finally, systematic inconsistencies and contradictions in the political process could undermine the credibility, effectiveness, and transparency of Brazil’s protected areas system and indigenous lands.

Read a summary of the article (link to journal)

Read the paper

Closed access

SEI author

Toby Gardner
Toby Gardner

Senior Research Fellow and former Trase Co-Director

SEI Headquarters

Read the paper
10.1126/science.1260194 Closed access
Regions
Amazon, Brazil