Skip navigation
Journal article

From evaluation to legacy: reflecting on over a decade of citizen science learning and impact

part of Citizen Science

In this paper, the authors explore how evaluation (particularly formative), participatory methods and ethically informed approaches can actively support more sustainable participant-centred legacies in citizen science.

Read the paper  Open access

Citation

Archer, R., West, S. E., Pateman, R., Beale, V., Bland, S., Dyke, A., Gooding, L., Safaya, S., & Way, L. (2026). From Evaluation to Legacy: Reflecting on Over a Decade of Citizen Science Learning and Impact. Citizen Science: Theory and Practice 11(1), 44. https://doi.org/10.5334/cstp.1005

Partners
Two women read and arrange colourful post-it notes on a whiteboard

Photo: Anjali Vyas-Brannick / SEI

In this paper the authors draw on nearly two decades of experience to answer two key questions:

  • How do you robustly evaluate a citizen science project whose long-term value and impacts often emerge only after formal funding has ended?
  • How do you conduct robust evaluation processes without burdening participants excessively?

SEI York’s Inclusive Citizen Science group is well-positioned to answer these questions. The team was founded through the pioneering Open Air Laboratories (OPAL) project in 2008. Since then, they have conducted citizen science and participatory research work with diverse participants on over 40 projects.

Early project evaluations tended to focus on participant numbers, metrics relating to activities and number of outputs. However, this did not always capture the information needed to to analyze the impact or success of the project. 

Iterating on these project processes, the group have adopted a number of approaches to make their evaluations more effective. They began using a Theory of Change to guide their work as a group, as well as producing theories of change for each of their projects. 

Taking pragmatic, participant-centred and inclusive approaches to activities during projects lays the foundation for effective evaluation as the work progresses. The team have conducted different forms of evaluation: co-evaluating projects with participants, evaluating projects with non-participating stakeholders (i.e. policymakers or officials who might work with the research produced), and conducting deep dives into the value of citizen science for participants have all improved the quality of evaluation materials.

Planning for a project’s legacy can also be informed by formative evaluation gathered along a project’s lifespan. This ensures that projects avoid ending abruptly as funding and staff contracts end and participants feel their involvement was truly valued. These processes can serve to heighten a project’s impact over the longer-term.

The authors give five key recommendations to those using citizen science methods:

  • Be intentional and pragmatic about evaluation.
  • Use a mix of approaches to conduct evaluation.
  • Design ethical, inclusive and participant-centred evaluation.
  • Plan for a project’s evaluation processes and legacy from the start.
  • Learn and share reflections on projects with the citizen science community.

Funded by

Read the paper

Open access

SEI authors

Rhys Archer

Research Associate

SEI York

Sarah West
Sarah West

Professor and Centre Director

SEI York

Rachel Pateman

SEI Affiliated Researcher

Victoria Beale

Communications Specialist

Communications

SEI York

Sam Bland
Sam Bland

Technical Specialist Software Engineer (RSE)

SEI York

Alison Dyke

Research Fellow

SEI York

Luke Gooding

Research Associate

SEI York

Smriti Safaya

Research Associate

SEI York

Lucy Way

Project Manager

SEI York

Read the paper
Citizen Science: Theory and Practice Open access
Topics and subtopics
Governance : Participation / Gender : Participation
Related centres
SEI York
Regions
United Kingdom